State of Wisconsin ex rel. Annette Flynn v. Kemper Center, Inc. (Public Records)

In State of Wisconsin ex rel. Annette Flynn v. Kemper Center, Inc. (2017AP1897), the Court of Appeals District II held that private corporation Kemper Center, Inc. is not a “quasi-governmental corporation” subject to the Wisconsin Public Records Law.

Kemper Center is a private corporation that leases property from Kenosha County and operates and maintains the property as a public park. Kenosha County provides some grants to Kemper Center, and other revenues come from rentals and user fees charged by Kemper Center.

Kenosha resident Annette Flynn filed a public records request for certain disclosures from Kemper Center. The issue before the court was whether Kemper Center is a “quasi-governmental corporation” under the definition of “authority” in Wis. Stat. §19.32(1), requiring it to disclose records to Flynn.

Citing factors from a previous Supreme Court decision that determined Beaver Dam Area Economic Development Corporation was a quasi-governmental corporation, the appeals court held that Kemper Center is not a quasi-governmental corporation because:

  1. Despite receiving grants from the County, Kemper Center is mostly funded by sources other than taxpayer dollars.
  2. While Kemper Center’s operation of the park does provide a public benefit, it does not provide an exclusively governmental function.
  3. Kemper Center does not have a public appearance of being governmental in nature. The court determined it is clear that the County owns the park, but Kemper Center, Inc.’s operation of the park does not appear governmental.
  4. The County does not have a significant degree of control over the Kemper Center operations.