Month: November 2010

Federal Court Dismisses Lead Paint Claims Against Manufacturers Based on “Risk Contribution” Theory

A federal district court this week in Milwaukee dismissed claims against defendants named in a lawsuit under the “risk contribution” rule adopted by the Wisconsin Supreme Court in 2005.

In Thomas v. Mallett, 2005 WI 129, 701 N.W.2d 523 (Wis. 2005), the Wisconsin Supreme Court in a 4-2 decision held that the manufacturers of white lead carbonate, which was used as a pigment in paint, were liable for the injuries caused to a child who had ingested paint that contained the white lead carbonate, although the child could not prove that a particular manufacturer produced the white lead carbonate that he ingested. Continue reading “Federal Court Dismisses Lead Paint Claims Against Manufacturers Based on “Risk Contribution” Theory”

Special Committee on Judicial Discipline and Recusal Unveils Proposed Draft Legislation

The Special Committee on Judicial Discipline and Recusal has unveiled its specific proposals dealing with judicial discipline and recusal. The Committee will discuss each item at its next meeting on Thursday, November 18 (10:00 a.m., Room 328 Northwest, State Capitol). It is not clear from the meeting agenda whether the Committee will formally vote to adopt these proposals and recommend them to the Legislature. WCJC will  provide updates as the Committee continues its work.

Below is a synopsis of each the eight draft proposals and a link to the actual language: Continue reading “Special Committee on Judicial Discipline and Recusal Unveils Proposed Draft Legislation”

Wisconsin Law Prohibiting Employers from Meeting with Employees Regarding Unions Preempted by Federal Law

In the waning days of the 2009-10 legislative session, the Wisconsin Legislature enacted SB 585 (2009 WI Act 290), which limited employers’ ability to meet with employees to discuss unions. Specifically, the law amended the Wisconsin Fair Employment Act to prohibit an employer from discharging or otherwise discriminating against an employee, or threatening to discharge an employee, because the employee declines to attend an employer-sponsored meeting.

The Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce and Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce sued the state arguing that the new law is preempted by the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) under the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution.

The state entered into to a stipulation declaring that the NLRA in fact preempts the amended law, thereby enjoining the Wisconsin Department of Workforce Development or any other state agency from enforcing the law.

Click here to view the stipulation entered into by WMC, MMAC and the state.

Lawsuit Abuse: NY Judge Rules 4-Year-Old Can Be Found Liable for Negligence

A New York court last week ruled that a four-year-old can be held liable for negligence. The New York Times describes how the young girl injured an elderly woman while riding her bicycle with training wheels on a Manhattan sidewalk.

The case, Menagh v. Breitman, has gained notoriety as another example of the plaintiffs’ bar abusing the civil justice system. Clearly, the purpose of this claim was to get at the little girl’s parents’ insurance since it highly unlikely the four-year-old has any assets of her own.